Books I’d Recommend: Five Days at Memorial by Sheri Fink

17 Oct
Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans flooding,

Large portions of New Orleans were flooded after the levees broke following Hurricane Katrina. This was shot Sept. 11, 2005. (Creative Commons: Lt. Commander Mark Moran, NOAA Corps, NMAO/AOC, 2005. Source: Flickr)

“Five Days At Memorial” is a compelling examination of Hurricane Katrina’s impact on one New Orleans hospital, the life-and-death decisions that were made in the following days and an examination of how improved disaster planning would benefit many organizations.

Author Sheri Fink’s work centers on Memorial Medical Center from Aug. 31, 2005, to Sept. 1, following the failure of the city’s levees in the wake of Katrina and the widespread flooding that caused throughout the city.

Five Days At MemorialBut the book also shows that the area around the hospital — located in the Freret neighborhood — experienced similar floods and similar challenges as far back as 1927. And it tells that the lessons learned from Katrina resulted in different outcomes in the wake of Superstorm Sandy on the East Coast in 2012.

At Memorial, staff battled stifling heat and the lack of water and electricity. They fought to keep patients alive and comfortable, evacuating some from a little-used helipad and others from airboats that floated the city streets.

Central to the story are the decisions regarding patients that it was feared could not survive evacuation. The book details how some DNR patients were given lethal dosages of morphine and a sedative. The state eventually charged an ER doctor and two ICU nurses with second degree murder. Charges were eventually dropped against the two nurses and a grand jury refused to indict the doctor.

The book is enthralling as it describes the challenges posed by the chaos and fears experienced during those first few days of the disaster. It poses moral dilemmas on how we deal with patients during times of high stress. And in the end, it helps you realize that we should all prepare to deal with the worst.

Fink, a former physician who won a Pulitzer Prize for the article that spawned the book, concludes her work with this:

Life and death in the immediate aftermath of a crisis most often depends on the preparedness, performance and decision making of the individuals on the scene.

It is hard for any of us to know how we would act under such terrible pressure.

But we, at least, have the luxury to prepare and resolve how we would want to make the decisions.

♦ ♦ ♦

Here’s a link to an NPR audiostory from “Morning Edition” on the book, plus a couple of written outtakes from the story. Perhaps most interesting are the many reader comments at the bottom of the story; most of the comments are critical toward Fink, but obviously most of the commenters have not read the book. I challenge you: Read the book, then return to read the comments. Whether you agree with the decisions made at Memorial during those trying times, it’s hard to fault Fink’s book, which relates many viewpoints in a reasoned manner.

In this Q&A with the New York Times, Fink explains many of the questions that arise in the book and how she went about recreating those hectic days. This is a really good read after you’ve read the book and understand many of the references mentioned.

You may eventually see this story on the big screen, following reports that the producer of “Captain Phillips” has acquired the movie rights to the book.


2 Responses to “Books I’d Recommend: Five Days at Memorial by Sheri Fink”

  1. Jim Brennan October 17, 2013 at 7:47 pm #

    Interesting. Thanks for blogging this.


    • msmidt October 17, 2013 at 7:49 pm #

      It’s a very interesting book — from the perspective of New Orleans, moral dilemmas and crisis management.


I'd love to read your comments!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Must Hike Must Eat

Sharing Trail Stories, Paleo Recipes and My Faith

Poetry In Motion

I'll stand before the Lord of Song / With nothing on my tongue but Hallelujah - Leonard Cohen

Running with Scissors

Careening through life as a mom, runner, ecologist, and writer

Hair with Samm

Images Hair Salon

Omni Running

Running for the fun of it

A trail running guy

A journey into running trails and ultra marathons

No Paine No Gain

Runner, writer - follow the adventure.

Hike Mt. Shasta

Exploring the Mount Shasta Region

Just Call Me Shortcut

thoughts from an ENFP who can't seem to stay on course

distance ahead


In the Shadow of the Rockies

Running the trails of Calgary, and beyond

Teton Romeo

Tails from Teton Valley, Idaho

Elevation Trail


Racing Through My Life

My Race Reports


where I do it all

Beaverhead 100K and 55K Endurance Runs

Run the remote and rugged Continental Divide National Scenic Trail in the Beaverhead Mountains dividing Idaho's Lemhi River Valley and Montana's Big Hole Valley.

The Daily Post

The Art and Craft of Blogging

One and a Half Runners

Don't be dumb in the first half, don't be a wimp in the second

amy c writes

words from a writer, runner and mama of twins


A topnotch site

Tim Tollefson

Trail junkie for Hoka One One; 2014 U.S. 50k Trail Champion; Physical Therapist, Mammoth Performance Lab Director; Coffee addict; Powered SRA Elite and GU; My wife and I have an open relationship with running...


Musings of a musician turned ultra runner

Running down a dream.

Ultra Runner Girl

Writing about running, war zones, and everything in between

Dan's Marathon

Running long distances across the country

Chasing 42

Life, the Universe, & Running

Ultrarunner Joe

My experiences and insights from out on the trail

Rambling on the run

What I think about when I think about running

Jack & Viv

Running, reading and raising a family

Bryan Odeen

give your soul some breathing room

%d bloggers like this: